Comparison of properties of different types of storage tanks

06 Aug.,2024

 

Comparison of properties of different types of storage tanks

Tank material Advantages Disadvantages Plastic Fiberglass
  • Commercially available
  • Alterable and movable (modular)
  • No leak fittings
  • Durable
  • Minimal maintenance needed
  • Light weight
  • If aboveground, must be sited on smooth, solid, level footing
  • Expensive in smaller sizes
Polyethylene, polypropylene
  • Commercially available
  • Alterable and movable
  • Affordable
  • Available in a variety of sizes
  • Easy to install
  • Little maintenance
  • Can be degraded by UV
  • If aboveground (outdoors), painted or tinted
  • Can be insultated and heat traced.
Barrels and trash cans
  • Commercially available
  • Inexpensive
  • Must use new cans
  • Small storage capacity
  • Rarely installed correctly
  • May lead to foundation water issues
Metal Galvanized steel tanks
  • Commercially available
  • Alterable and movable
  • Available in variety of sizes
  • Possible corrosion and rust
  • Must be lined for potable use
  • Only above-ground use
  • Must be insulated and heat traced
Steel drums (55-gallon)
  • Commercially available
  • Alterable and movable
  • Verify prior to use for toxics
  • Corrosion and rust can leach metals
  • Small storage capacity
Concrete and masonry Ferroconcrete
  • Durable
  • Versatile
  • Suitable for above- or below-ground installations
  • Can be incorporated into the foundation of a building.
  • Potential to crack and leak
  • Permanent
Monolithic/poured-in-place
  • Durable
  • Suitable for above- or below-ground installations
  • Neutralizes acid rain
  • Can be incorporated into the foundation of a building.
  • Potential to crack and leak
  • Permanent
  • Need drainage in clay soil
Stone, concrete block
  • Durable
  • Keeps water cool in hot weather
  • Difficult to maintain and sanitize
  • Permanent
  • Expensive to build
  • Could harbor biofilms
Wood Pine, redwood, cedar, cypress
  • Attractive
  • Durable
  • Can be disassembled
  • Available in variety of sizes
  • Expensive
  • Require skilled technician to build
  • Not for use in hot, dry conditions
  • Can be leaky
  • Only above-ground use
  • Not as easily sanitized

Galvanized Steel vs Stainless Steel: Which Is the Better ...

Customers often want to know which is better, galvanized steel or stainless steel? Which is more expensive? Which holds up better against the elements? The simple fact is that neither kind of steel is always the better choice in every situation. Here are some of the basics about galvanized and stainless steel you can use to make optimal selections.

Longzhuo Product Page

What is Galvanized Steel?

Galvanized steel is coated with a thin layer of zinc. The zinc coating protects the steel beneath it from rust. It&#;s used to make nuts, bolts, screws, and nails resistant to degradation when they are exposed to the weather. Galvanized steel stands up to water well &#; as long as it&#;s not salt water. Welders who work with structural steel can work with galvanized steel, although they will need protection against breathing the fumes.

What is Stainless Steel?

Stainless steel is made by adding chromium to molten steel. It is unusually strong and resistant to rusting caused by contact with water, even salt water. Welding stainless steel is a specialized skill. Welders must exercise much more control when heating and cooling stainless steel. And they must take special care to match filler materials with the steel being welded.

Engineers and architects need to keep up with differences in types of stainless steel. Austenitic stainless steel is the product you might use in a machine shop. Ferritic stainless steel is a cheaper product that is used in applications that are easy to replace, like automobile exhaust pipes. Long-wearing martenistic steel is used for hardfacing. Duplex stainless steel combines the molecular structures of austenitic and ferritic stainless steel but it is hard to work with. Precipitation-hardening stainless steel is made by adding another rare metal like niobium for even more strength, most often for aerospace applications. The more complex the alloy, generally the greater the strength, the higher the price, and the greater the labor costs.

In general, galvanized steel is more ductile, and easier to work than stainless steel. Stainless steel is stronger and more corrosion-resistant than galvanized steel.

What is the Difference in Price?

Galvanized steel is almost the same price as untreated structural steel. Stainless steel costs four to five times as much as galvanized steel and untreated structural steel. Niobium alloys are even more expensive.

For more information, please visit galvanized steel tank.

Which Kind of Steel Stands up Better?

As you look through the characteristics of these two types of steel, you can see they are very different from each other. Both kinds of steel are applicable to a huge range of products, but one type will always be a better choice than the other.

There are situations in which you need to stay away from stainless steel. This product stands up to salt water, but it is quickly degraded after exposure to chlorinated water. You also need to avoid any design in which two stainless steel components generate friction against each other. They can weld themselves together.

As great as galvanized steel is, there are also situations in which the choice of galvanized steel needs additional consideration. Usually, steel should be welded before it is galvanized, not after. Welding steel after it has been galvanized burns away the protective layer of zinc at the weld. It may be necessary to regalvanize galvanized steel after it is welded to protect the joint.

If you are building the rocket that will send the Space Force to Mars, you will probably need to work with stainless steel. You will also need stainless steel if you get a contract to build an ocean-bound submarine. But for most down to earth uses of steel on land, your most economical choice, in terms of both material and labor costs and life of the project, will be galvanized steel.

Want more information on plate clarifier? Feel free to contact us.