Are you in the market for butterfly valves? Look no further! This ultimate buyer&#;s guide has got you covered. Whether you&#;re a seasoned professional or a beginner in the world of valves, this comprehensive guide will provide you with everything you need to know.
If you are looking for more details, kindly visit our website.
Butterfly valves are an essential component in many industries, including oil and gas, water treatment, and manufacturing. They offer excellent flow control and are known for their reliability and ease of operation.
In this guide, we&#;ll dive into the different types of butterfly valves, their applications, and the key factors to consider when making a purchasing decision. We&#;ll explore the benefits of different materials, explain how to choose the right size and connection type and highlight important features to look for.
Don&#;t make a decision without arming yourself with the knowledge in this guide. With our expert advice, you&#;ll be able to confidently find the perfect butterfly valve to meet your needs. So, let&#;s get started and find the valve that will keep your operations running smoothly.
Butterfly valves come in various types, each designed to meet specific industry needs. Let&#;s explore the most common types:
1. Wafer Style Butterfly Valves: These valves are lightweight and compact, making them ideal for applications with limited space. They are installed between two flanges and held in place using bolts.
2. Lug Style Butterfly Valves: Lug style valves have threaded inserts on both sides of the valve&#;s body. This design allows for easy installation and removal without disrupting the pipeline.
3. Double Offset Butterfly Valves: Double offset valves have a unique design that reduces wear and extends the valve&#;s lifespan. They are commonly used in high-pressure applications and offer excellent sealing capabilities.
4. Triple Offset Butterfly Valves: Triple offset valves are the most advanced type of butterfly valves. They have a metal seat that ensures a tight shut-off, even in high-temperature and high-pressure environments.
Butterfly valves offer several advantages that make them a popular choice in many industries. Let&#;s take a closer look:
1. Cost-effective: Butterfly valves are generally more affordable than other types of valves, making them a cost-effective option, especially for large-scale projects.
2. Quick and easy operation: Butterfly valves can be operated quickly and easily, thanks to their simple design. This allows for efficient flow control and minimizes downtime during maintenance.
3. Compact and lightweight: Butterfly valves are much lighter and more compact than other valve types, making them easier to install and transport. This can save both time and money during the installation process.
Despite their many advantages, butterfly valves also have a few disadvantages to consider:
1. Limited sealing capabilities: While butterfly valves provide good sealing in most applications, they may not be suitable for extremely high-pressure or high-temperature environments where a tight shut-off is crucial.
2. Throttling limitations: Butterfly valves are best suited for on/off applications rather than precise throttling. If precise flow control is required, a different valve type may be more appropriate.
When choosing a butterfly valve, several factors should be taken into account to ensure the valve meets your specific needs. Here are the key factors to consider:
1. Application: Consider the specific application and operating conditions in which the valve will be used. Different industries and processes have unique requirements that must be considered when selecting a butterfly valve.
2. Valve Size: The size of the valve is determined by the diameter of the pipe it will be installed in. Selecting the correct valve size is crucial for optimal performance and flow control.
3. Connection Type: Butterfly valves can be fitted with different connection types, including wafer, lug, and flanged connections. Choose the connection type that best suits your installation requirements and ensures a secure and leak-free connection.
4. Material Selection: The choice of material for the valve body, disc, and seat depends on the application and the specific media that will flow through the valve. Common materials include stainless steel, cast iron, and PVC.
Butterfly valves are available in a wide range of materials, each offering unique properties and benefits. The choice of material depends on the specific application and the media that will flow through the valve. Here are some commonly used materials:
1. Stainless Steel: Stainless steel is a popular choice for butterfly valves due to its corrosion resistance and durability. It is suitable for a wide range of applications, including food and beverage, pharmaceutical, and chemical industries.
2. Cast Iron: Cast iron valves are known for their strength and durability. They are commonly used in applications where high pressure and temperature resistance are required, such as water treatment plants and HVAC systems.
3. PVC: PVC butterfly valves are lightweight and cost-effective. They are widely used in the water and wastewater industry due to their excellent chemical resistance and affordability.
Proper valve sizing is essential for ensuring optimal performance and flow control. Here&#;s what you need to know about butterfly valve sizing:
1. Pipe Diameter: The valve size should match the diameter of the pipe it will be installed in. Undersized or oversized valves can lead to poor performance and increased pressure drop.
2. Flow Coefficient (Cv): The flow coefficient is a measure of the valve&#;s capacity to pass fluid. It determines the flow rate at a given pressure drop. The Cv value should be carefully calculated based on the desired flow rate and system requirements.
3. Pressure Ratings: Butterfly valves have maximum pressure ratings that should not be exceeded to prevent valve failure. It is important to consider the maximum operating pressure of the system when selecting a butterfly valve.
Proper installation and regular maintenance are crucial for ensuring the longevity and optimal performance of butterfly valves. Here are some important considerations:
1. Installation: Follow the manufacturer&#;s guidelines for proper installation, including the correct orientation and torque specifications. Ensure that the valve is aligned with the piping system to prevent leaks and ensure smooth operation.
2. Regular Inspections: Regularly inspect the valve for any signs of wear, damage, or leakage. Pay attention to the sealing surfaces, stem, and actuator for any signs of corrosion or deterioration.
3. Maintenance: Lubricate the valve stem and maintain proper actuator performance. Replace any worn-out parts or damaged seals to prevent valve failure.
Butterfly valves find applications in various industries, including:
1. Oil and Gas: Butterfly valves are commonly used in oil and gas pipelines for their quick operation, low-pressure drop, and cost-effectiveness.
2. Water and Wastewater: Butterfly valves are widely used in water treatment plants and wastewater facilities due to their excellent flow control and corrosion resistance.
3. Chemical and Petrochemical: Butterfly valves are suitable for handling a wide range of chemicals and corrosive substances, making them a popular choice in chemical and petrochemical industries.
When it comes to purchasing butterfly valves, there are several reputable manufacturers and suppliers to consider. Here are some top names in the industry:
1. Emerson: Emerson offers a wide range of butterfly valves suitable for various industries and applications. Their valves are known for their reliability and high performance.
2. Flowserve: Flowserve manufactures butterfly valves that are designed to meet the most demanding requirements of critical applications. Their valves offer excellent durability and longevity.
3. Tyco: Tyco (now part of Johnson Controls) is a leading supplier of butterfly valves, offering a comprehensive range of products for different industries, including fire protection, HVAC, and water management.
Conclusion and recommendations
In conclusion, butterfly valves are versatile and cost-effective solutions for flow control in various industries. When selecting a butterfly valve, consider the specific application, valve size, connection type, and material compatibility. Regular maintenance and proper installation are essential for ensuring optimal performance and longevity.
Based on your specific requirements, consult with reputable manufacturers and suppliers to find the perfect butterfly valve that meets your needs. With the knowledge gained from this ultimate buyer&#;s guide, you can confidently make an informed purchasing decision that will keep your operations running smoothly.
Remember, the right butterfly valve is key to achieving efficient flow control and maximizing productivity in your industry. So, make sure to take the time to research and choose wisely. Happy valve shopping!
&#;
Disclaimer: The mentioned manufacturers and suppliers are for illustrative purposes only and do not constitute an endorsement.
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS
Log In
Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving . By joining you are opting in to receive .
With competitive price and timely delivery, Yaxing Valve sincerely hope to be your supplier and partner.
Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.
Eng-Tips Posting Policies
Butterfly versus Gate Valves
thread408- Forum Search FAQs Links MVPsForum
Search
FAQs
Links
MVPs
(Civil/Environmental)
(OP)
2 Dec 10 11:40I apologize if this topic has been discussed before. I could not find it using the search tool. I work for a water supplier and I am responcible for writing specs. We have repeatedly argued over what valve is superior in a distribution system and a transmission system. Our system is over 100 years old. We have pressures ranging from 40-PSI to 150-PSI. We originally installed double disc gate valves with integral bypass valves. We are seeing failures of some of these valves and are writing specs to replace them. Should we go with butterfly valves? What are the pros and cons to each? We are also considering resilient wedge gate valves, but some are questioning the life expectancy of the rubber. Is that an issue?
Thanks in advance for any help!!!
Replies continue below
(Mechanical)
2 Dec 10 11:50I see the biggest problem you may have in replacing a Gate Valve with a Butterfly Valve is the vast difference in the face to face dimension of the two valves.
Modifying one hundred year old piping to accept the different face to face dimension might introduce more trouble than you can stand from a cost standpoint.
Think it over and talk it out before you make the final decision.
(Mechanical)
2 Dec 10 12:09That is a good point penpiper, but it is deeper than that. Valves made in the 19th century were not built to a standard flange-to-flange dimension, and virtually any modern valve that you buy will require piping modification--adding a 1-inch pup is pretty similar to adding a 6-inch pup.
My experience with gate valves (both as an operator and a designer) is that they are quite tedious to operate. A quarter turn valve is a lot less tedius (even with a gear operator). You've limited your universe to gate valves and butterfly valves. Some reason you've excluded ball valves? If long-term maintenance is a driving characteristic I would bet that ball valves would give you superior performance for about the same money as gate valves.
I'm not a fan of butterfly valves in most applications. My experience with them has been that the resilliant seat doesn't last decades, and that for high-velocity flows, the von Karmen streets downstream of the open flapper can represent a lot of force on the rod holding the flapper in place. A lot of people use them "successfully" (whatever their individual definition of "success" is), I just never have.
David
(Mechanical)
2 Dec 10 13:13Biggest con I see with butterfly valves vs gate valves is that you have the disc sitting in the stream with butterfly valves which means less flow and wear on the disc. I would imagine that the maintenance on them is much greater.
the pros is that they are lighter weight and only quarter turn so they operate faster and since they are usually soft seated they have a better shutoff vs metal seated gate valves.
I think it depends on the size when talking ball valves. On smaller sizes I think the extra cost of the ball might be worth the switch But large diameter ball valves are quite expensive and I'm not sure the switch from gate valves is worth the extra cost.
You didn't really say but it appears that the gate valves in your system lasted quite a long time so another fact to consider is it worth changing the system parameters for something you know worked for decades?
(Civil/Environmental)
(OP)
2 Dec 10 15:41Thanks so far!!!
I think a little clarification is needed. Valves were mostly direct bury with either bell by bell or spigot ends with poured lead joints. Replacing those we would cut the cast iron pipe on each side and replace with mechanical joints. Small spool pieces of ductile iron would be inserted into the mechanical joints and couplings would secure the new valve to the old cast iron. In addition, some type of clamp, such as the steel restraint clamps supplied by Ford, and 1-inch threaded rods all wrapped with wax paper for restraint.
Valves in vaults may have been flange by flange, so the above about spacing and cost could be correct.
We still have the ongoing disagreement over which valve is superior or more correctly which valve should be used when and for what reasons.
Here are some of the arguments I have to address:
butterfly valves are easier to operate, they cost less, they do not seal tightly, they can be throttled, the seats could be damaged during throttling
gate valves are hard to operate, they cost more, they are designed to seal tightly, they can not be throttled,
the rubber used for resilient wedge gate valve and/or the resilient seat on butterfly valves may not have a design life of 100 years and may be as little as 30years
Should I be considering going back to a metal seated double disc design???
(Mechanical)
2 Dec 10 17:47If butterfly jams open how do you get it out?Butterfly valves are not considered a satsfactory form of isolation in a double isolation scenario.Wafer type butterfly valves are not an effective form of isolation when the downstream piping is removed for maintenance.A full bodied flanged double or triple eccentric butterfly valve (ie a real one) will cost you more than a gate valve.Resilient seats can be ripped out in a waterhammer event.If the spindle of a butterfly valve is in the vertical the bottom bearing gets contaminated and will wear prematurely.Any debris in the stream will jam the disc of a butterfly valve and damage the seat.You cannot pass a pig or sponge ball through a butterfly valve if scouring out the crypto or giardia in the sludge.
(Mechanical)
3 Dec 10 04:47I see you fail to mention the common diameters of the valve, and also your country. By watermains in Europ with longlife requirement, it is most common to use double eccentric butterfly valves, but not!from high-quality producers.Mains in this case would be pipelines for pressure class PN10, PN16 and PN25 (bars) and dimensions from about DN150/DN200 or somewhat higher, for instance from DN250See for instance www.erhard.de (several others)Note: with lifetime IP68 gear.With gear placed correctly (when ordered), valve stem will remain horizontal with gear-operaator spindle up.For theese types of double eccentric butterfly valves the quality of valve, gear, sealing construction and general flow charecteristic, way of operation and lifetime expectancy will be far above centric butterfly valves, and much cheaper than ballvalves.The seat sealing construction (seals with integrated sealrings secured adjustable and mounted on the disc) will not be ripped out by waterhammer for this type of valve.Valves might be throtteled for smaller delta Ps with slightly better charecteristics than a common centric valve, and somewhat increased range, but will of course cavitate by throtteling at higher delta Ps' as centric valves.The geometrical and seal construction will give thight lifetime sealing.For 100 years lifetime for theese dimensions the double eccentric ballvalve (sample: same factory) could also be considered.For smaller valves in the street distribution net: different type of gatevalves or ballvalves.You need to do a cost over lifetime study before you choose types, but overall valve quality is highly important, and when asking for (preliminary?) bids you should ask for alternative types and quotes from all suppliers and a technical argumentation following the bid, and also references.Very often today quotes tend or have to be ordered from cheapest offer, not highest quality of else (only seemingly) socalled 'equal types' from different manufacturors.Advice: do not stress your inquiries with 'overspecification', stress instead lifetime and standtime importance and let the factory suggest or offer additions, materials and even types of solutions to give the best result.An easy understood example: a 'gear' on a valve can be many different things, but in reality vastly different in operational torque, construction, materials and protection.If you look at a commen valvesheet this will very often be described as 'with gear and (x) length extension.'See the point?If you do not ask for alternatives of highest available quality, or allow for this in competition comparison, you will end up with the cheapest gear available - not the best cost/lifetime solution.- and for the valves it is even more complicated: small differences in construction can give large differences over 100 years, for instance exposed or not exposed inner bolts, and details on bolts and material quality.Good luck!
(Petroleum)
7 Dec 10 16:17In most water service, I see gate valves. One reason maybe that there is nothing in the flow path for debris to hang up on. With a butterfly, if there are debris, it may prevent the butterfly from closing properly/completely.
"Do not worry about your problems with mathematics, I assure you mine are far greater."
Albert Einstein
Have you read FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies to make the best use of Eng-Tips Forums?
(Mechanical)
13 Dec 10 12:02Resilient seated valves will provide 0 leakage for the beginning of it's life and leak more and more as it ages. I would not use any resilient seats for valves difficult to maintain. Nor would I recommend such valves for 100 year service...
Some things to consider:
- Do you need bubble tight shutoff? (resilience vs metal seat)
- How often can you afford to change seats? (butterfly)
- Would the valves be used as isolation valves? (butterfly type, number of valves)
- How often would the valves need to be actuated? (quarter turn vs multi turn)
- Is throttling necessary? (butterfly/ball vs gate) please note many valves are not designed to be throttled for extended periods
- Emission requirements? (quarter turn is better)
- Pigability? (normal gate/butterfly out of question)
- Solids in the medium (resilient vs hardfacing vs material selection)
- Dead end service
Personally, it seems the double wedge valves were used for DBB isolation service, the best replacement for it would be.. the same thing... or as reverman say, ball valve. I don't see resilient butterfly valve a good candidate and you would need two butterfly valves for safe DBB.
Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.
Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.
Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members! Already a Member? Login
Contact us to discuss your requirements of What is a Butterfly Valve. Our experienced sales team can help you identify the options that best suit your needs.